Recipe Box | Shopping CartSearch Products  
 border=

Go
 

   
Assuming you are working with a well-balanced formula, when a cake falls, peaks and cracks, or has poor texture, the first thing to consider is the oven temperature. The next is the proportion of ingredients (how they are weighed or measured). Incorrect substitutions without adjustments are often the problem; jumbo eggs instead of large, all purpose flour instead of cake flour without making necessary adjustment, old baking powder.

Assuming you are following directions precisely and has accurately weighed or measured the ingredients, the most common cake problems and causes are:

Burnt on bottom with undercooked batter Falls
Burns on sides Falls apart when taken out of pan
Coarse grain Heavy and compact
Cracked or peaked cake Humps or cracks on top
Crust is cracked Rises higher on one side than the other
Crust is sticky Runs over top of pan
Crust is tough Soggy layer or streak at bottom
Crust too hard Sticks to pan
Crust too light in color Too light, crumbly and dry
Crust is soggy or doughy Tough
Does not rise, compact texture Undersized
Dry

Burnt on bottom with undercooked batter

Cause:
Inadequate air circulation in oven

Burns on sides

Cause:
Uneven heat in oven
Oven too full
Oven too hot
Baked too near sides of oven

Coarse grain

Cause:
Too much leavening
Insufficient creaming
Use of liquid shortening
Use of ordinary flour
Oven temperature too low
Batter under mixed
Too much baking powder

Cracked or peaked cake

Cause:
Oven too hot
Batter over mixed

Crust is cracked

Cause:
Too much sugar
Damp flour

Crust is sticky

Cause:
Too much sugar
Insufficient baking
Damp flour

Crust is tough

Cause:
Not enough shortening
Not enough sugar
Too much flour
Oven too hot
Cake baked too long

Crust too hard

Cause:
Oven too hot
Cake baked too long

Crust too light in color

Cause:
Oven not hot enough
Not enough sugar
Not enough leavening
Not enough shortening

Crust is soggy or doughy

Cause:
Cake let steam while cooling

Does not rise, compact texture

Cause:
Old or too little baking powder
Cold eggs
Cold butter

Dry

Cause:
Too much flour
Too much leavening
Not enough shortening
Not enough liquid
Not enough sugar
Over beaten egg whites
Over baked or baked too long or at too low temperature
Pan too big

Falls

Cause:
Too much shortening
Too much baking powder or soda over leavens mixture
Too much sugar
Batter under mixed
Insufficient baking
Oven temperature too low

Falls apart when taken out of pan

Cause:
Too much shortening
Too much leavening
Too much sugar

Heavy and compact

Cause:
Over beating batter
Too much shortening
Not enough sugar
Too much liquid
Under beaten yolks
Incorrect baking temperature

Humps or cracks on top

Cause:
Oven too hot at first
Too much flour
Not enough liquid

Rises higher on one side than the other

Cause:
Uneven heat in oven
Oven grate not level
Batter spread unevenly in pan

Runs over top of pan

Cause:
Too much batter in pan
Oven not hot enough
Too much leavening
Too much shortening or sugar

Soggy layer or streak at bottom

Cause:
Under mixing of ingredients
Shortening too soft
Not enough leavening
Lower part of oven not hot enough
Under beaten yolks
Too much liquid
Damp flour

Sticks to pan

Cause:
Pan not properly prepared
Cake left in pan too long
Too much sugar

Too light, crumbly and dry

Cause:
Too much leavening

Tough

Cause:
Not enough shortening
Not enough sugar
Over beating batter
Oven too hot

Undersized

Cause:
Not enough baking powder or soda to leaven the mixture.
Mixture baked in too large a pan
Oven too hot

Home|Log In|Sign Up
All content materials © The Art Of Baking